How to Set an MTG Cube Power Level Without Chasing Every Staple

TLDR

Set your MTG cube power level by describing the games you want, not by assigning the list an arbitrary number. Decide how fast decks should become functional, how efficient answers should be, how easily players may splash colors, and how consistently each supported archetype should execute its plan. Then look for cards or packages that bypass those expectations.

A powerful Cube does not need every famous staple. In fact, removing a few cards that are dramatically stronger, safer, or easier to splash than everything around them can make the remaining cards feel more powerful because more picks and strategies become credible.

Define MTG cube power level as an experience

Cube power level is contextual. A card is not merely powerful in isolation; its strength depends on the answers, mana, threats, and competing strategies available in the same environment. Lucky Paper’s useful treatment of Cube power level as an environment-level concept emphasizes whether different cards and strategies remain mutually playable, rather than reducing the Cube to a universal score.

Start with a short experience statement. It should describe what players are expected to do and how games should feel. For example: “This is a proactive two-color Cube where decks establish a plan by turn three, interaction is efficient but usually color-committal, and synergy decks can beat generic value piles when they come together.”

That sentence gives you more guidance than calling the Cube a seven out of ten. It tells you what cheap creatures must accomplish, how good removal can be, whether four- and five-color decks are welcome, and how much support a narrow build-around needs.

Wizards’ Cube-building guidance similarly recommends beginning with themes, strategies, and the intended player experience rather than assembling a pile of individually strong cards. Playtesting then reveals which themes do not have enough support.

Define these five properties before changing individual cards:

  • Speed: On what turn should proactive decks apply meaningful pressure or assemble their engines?
  • Efficiency: How much mana should threats, card advantage, and answers cost relative to one another?
  • Reliability: How often should a drafted deck execute its primary plan?
  • Mana access: Should players normally stay in two colors, splash selectively, or build broad multicolor decks?
  • Interaction: Which threats should be answerable, by which colors, and at what cost?

Find cards that break the Cube’s promise

A power outlier is not simply the strongest card in a Cube. Every environment has a best card. The problem is a card whose efficiency, flexibility, or reliability distorts decisions around it.

Outliers often become unusually safe early picks, appear in more final decks, and pull players toward a particular strategy. Exceptionally strong cards can also affect draft signaling because players take them earlier and play them more consistently than ordinary Cube cards.

Audit a suspected outlier with five questions:

  1. Is it an automatic early pick for several different decks?
  2. Can decks splash it without accepting a meaningful mana cost?
  3. Does it demand an immediate answer while trading favorably with most available answers?
  4. Does it make similar cards or entire strategies difficult to justify?
  5. Does taking it repeatedly pull drafters into the same generic shell?

One “yes” is not a conviction. A flexible land or removal spell is supposed to fit multiple decks. Several yeses, backed by repeated drafts, indicate gravitational pull worth investigating.

When an outlier is an intentional feature

Outliers can be part of the attraction. A high-powered Cube may deliberately include explosive mana, game-ending reanimation targets, or premium interaction. Keep such cards when your experience statement promises dramatic starts and players enjoy drafting around them.

The important question is whether the rest of the environment acknowledges that feature. Fast mana changes which expensive cards are realistic. Premium reanimation needs suitable enablers, targets, and disruption. A spectacular card supported by a connected package creates a strategy; a spectacular card that simply goes into everything creates a first-pick contest.

Keep games powerful without homogenizing drafts

Homogenization happens when the safest route is to take efficient cards, collect broad fixing, and postpone commitment indefinitely. Wizards has discussed how powerful fixing and artifact mana can encourage similar multicolor midrange decks in Cube design. The answer is not necessarily to make every card weaker. It is to make power available through distinct routes.

Give each major deck family an advantage that others cannot reproduce merely by drafting expensive cards. Aggro can have superior early pressure and reach. Control can have inevitability and selective sweepers. Midrange can have resilient threats and flexible interaction. Combo can convert setup work into an effect unavailable to generic decks.

Build connected packages rather than chasing a checklist of staples. If a card is excellent only when surrounded by artifacts, sacrifice fodder, graveyard enablers, or cheap creatures, it rewards drafting decisions. If every premium card is generically efficient and easy to cast, the draft offers fewer reasons to commit.

Overlap still matters. Cards that serve more than one strategy let drafters stay flexible and pivot when a lane closes. The goal is productive overlap: a sacrifice card might support both an aggressive deck and a graveyard engine without becoming an automatic inclusion in every black deck. For a deeper framework, see balancing aggro, midrange, control, and combo.

Tune removal by rate and flexibility, not only count

Removal density matters, but two Cubes with the same number of answers can play completely differently. A cheap spell that answers nearly any threat at instant speed is a larger power lever than a conditional answer costing an extra mana.

Low-cost interaction can generate favorable tempo exchanges against expensive threats. If nearly every answer is both cheap and universal, players may avoid synergy-dependent or expensive threats because the risk is too high. If interaction is slow or narrow across the board, whichever player establishes the first strong engine may be difficult to stop.

Evaluate removal across four dimensions:

Dimension Question to ask Likely effect when increased
Mana efficiency How cheaply can a threat be answered? More tempo-oriented games and greater pressure on expensive threats
Breadth How many permanent types or mana values can it hit? Safer picks and fewer unanswered threat classes
Speed Can it be used at instant speed? More reactive play and less risk from holding up mana
Card economy Does it trade one-for-one, sweep, or generate value? Changes how readily decks can recover or pull ahead

Match answers to the threats you actually support. Expensive creatures need some protection, immediate value, or a favorable matchup against common removal. Aggro needs enough cheap threats that one-for-one answers do not erase its entire start. Control needs answers it can cast before falling hopelessly behind. Sweepers deserve their own review because their visibility and flexibility affect creature decks differently; use the guide to choosing a Cube sweeper count as a starting framework.

Use fixing to enforce the color decisions you want

Fixing affects more than whether players cast their spells. It determines how long a drafter can avoid committing, how costly a splash is, and whether dedicated two-color decks have an advantage over broad good-stuff piles.

For a mostly two-color environment, draftable fixing lands equal to roughly 10–12% of Cube slots can be a starting heuristic, not a universal target. That works out to about 36–43 lands in 360 cards or 54–65 in 540. Cube speed, color requirements, desired splash frequency, and the quality of the lands should move the final number. The full Cube fixing-land guide explains those adjustments.

Quality matters as much as quantity. Fixing that enters untapped, covers several colors, or carries little opportunity cost makes splashing easier than narrower or slower lands. Artifact mana can also alter color access while accelerating expensive plays. Count what your mana sources enable, not merely how many land slots you assigned.

If aggressive decks struggle, examine the mana before adding stronger threats. Slow fixing may punish aggro by giving it free time, while abundant untapped fixing may let midrange decks cast the best cheap cards from several colors. Either extreme can work, but it should match the intended experience.

Adjust archetype support as power rises

Higher power increases the cost of drawing cards that do not contribute quickly or reliably. That usually means an archetype needs better redundancy, more flexible enablers, or a larger payoff for accepting narrow cards.

  • Aggro needs a dependable early curve, enough reach, and mana that does not force it to lose a turn. A few famous one-drops cannot carry the entire section. See how much aggro support a Cube needs for a fuller audit.
  • Midrange needs reasons to exist beyond taking every flexible card. Resilient threats, creature-based synergies, and color-specific strengths give it an identity without making it the default home for every first pick.
  • Control needs early interaction, card advantage, and credible finishers. Its answers should line up with the environment, but universal answers at bargain rates can crowd out other reactive choices.
  • Combo needs sufficient enablers, payoffs, and protection within the portion of the Cube a pod sees. Flexible pieces reduce failed drafts, but the payoff should justify the setup cost.

Redundancy becomes especially important as the Cube grows. An eight-player draft using three 15-card packs per player consumes 8 × 3 × 15 = 360 cards. In a 540-card Cube, 180 cards remain unseen, so a drafter cannot depend on any single support card appearing. That partial exposure is a feature for replay variety, but it means essential roles need multiple suitable cards. The 360-versus-540 tradeoff is therefore also a power-level decision.

Run a 540-card power-level audit

Do not rebuild the list after one odd draft. Make small, connected changes and track whether they solve the actual problem.

  1. Write the intended experience in one or two sentences.
  2. Review first picks and final decks for cards that are powerful, safe, and easily splashed at the same time.
  3. Identify which winning decks recur. Separate healthy archetype success from the same generic shell wearing different basic lands.
  4. Check whether removal trades at the rate you intended against both cheap and expensive threats.
  5. Review fixing quantity, fixing quality, artifact mana, and color requirements together.
  6. For each archetype, count enablers, payoffs, interaction, and flexible overlap within a plausible 360-card sample—not only across the full 540.
  7. Change a small package, such as two overbroad answers plus two weak threats, rather than swapping unrelated singles.
  8. Record draft position, broad deck type, match result, cards that routinely remained in sideboards, and any pick that felt automatic. Review patterns after several drafts.

Use more than one draft method if your group changes size. Booster Draft provides the familiar eight-player baseline, while smaller formats expose different pressures on synergy and card visibility. The guide to MTG Cube draft formats can help you select a test that matches the group that will actually play the Cube.

Choose the experience, then choose the cards

A coherent MTG cube power level comes from systems working together. Threats, answers, fixing, acceleration, and archetype packages should all reinforce the same promise. Staples are optional; coherence is not.

Start by writing the experience statement, then inspect the cards with the greatest gravitational pull. If one card is too efficient for the available answers, adjust the card or the answers. If fixing erases color commitment, change its quality or quantity. If a synergy deck cannot assemble within the cards a pod sees, add redundancy or remove the unsupported package.

Once the list is ready, owners who need a custom card-creation and print-order route can explore custom MTG card printing through PrintMTG. The more important first step, however, is free: decide what kind of draft night the Cube is supposed to produce. That decision makes every later cut much easier.

References

  1. Cube Power Level: A User’s Guide — Lucky Paper
  2. Building Your First Cube | MAGIC: THE GATHERING
  3. Power, Cubed | MAGIC: THE GATHERING
  4. MTG Cube Archetypes: How to Balance Aggro, Midrange, Control, and Combo – Hundred Dollar Cube
  5. How Many Fixing Lands Should an MTG Cube Have? – Hundred Dollar Cube